All 24 exits ranked by what a road-tripper actually needs: real food choice, easy gas, 24-hour service, and the stops worth a detour. Winners below.
Milepost 28.5 · 26 places to eat · 11 gas stations · 4 hotels · ♥ North Shore Historical Museum, Holocaust Museum and Tolerance Center
Milepost 0 · 29 places to eat · 13 gas stations · 10 hotels · ♥ Ringwood State Park, Campgaw Mountain Reservation
Milepost 10.7 · 53 places to eat · 18 gas stations · 9 hotels · ♥ Hook Mountain State Park, Titus Mill Pond State Tidal Wetlands
Milepost 16.5 · 29 places to eat · 12 gas stations · 11 hotels · ♥ Lyndhurst Mansion, Tallman Mountain State Park
Milepost 8.5 · 27 places to eat · 11 gas stations · 4 hotels · open 24 hours · ♥ High Tor State Park
Milepost 2.1 · 29 places to eat · 5 gas stations · 2 hotels · ♥ Walwick Museum of Local History, Erie Railroad Signal Tower, Waldwick Yard
Milepost 6.2 · 23 places to eat · 14 gas stations · 6 hotels · ♥ The Hermitage
Milepost 13 · 38 places to eat · 17 gas stations · 8 hotels · ♥ Blauvelt State Park
Milepost 17.5 · 31 places to eat · 20 gas stations · 21 hotels · ♥ Rockefeller State Park Preserve
Milepost 7 · 29 places to eat · 14 gas stations · 8 hotels · open 24 hours
← Every I-287 exit in New York
Pit Stop shows gas, food, hotels & must-see stops at every exit ahead — $1.99 once, offline, on iPhone & CarPlay.